Prophecy Girl

Written by

·

Sarah Michelle Gellar as Buffy Summers in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, season 1 (1997) Costume design: Susanna Puisto. Photo: Richard Cartwright. Image: 20th Century Fox / EW.com.

With news of a Buffy revival in the works, this costumes post is devoted to the iconic Buffy Summers.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997-2003) was so influential that it’s easy to forget that it started as a mid-season replacement, with its first season conceived to stand alone. Season 1 costume designer Susanna Puisto was an ex-model and fashion insider who combined new and established designer labels with custom and vintage looks, especially vintage leather. When the show was renewed for a second season, the network brought in Cynthia Bergstrom (Scream), who worked with Sarah Michelle Gellar to develop Buffy’s maturing style.

Promotional image for Buffy the Vampire Slayer (season 3, ca. 1999) Costume designer: Cynthia Bergstrom. Image: Pinterest.

In the first season, Puisto dressed Buffy in piece after piece of what would become the character’s signature: leather and animal prints. A few late-’90s Vogue Elements designs for synthetic leather seem to reference Buffy Summers. Buffy-esque styles in this pattern line include a mini skirt with side slit, red tapered pants, and oxblood leather coat. Plus, appropriately for the Slayer, these patterns are also sized for petites.

Vogue Elements skirt pattern Vogue 9773 (1997) Image: eBay.
Vogue Elements tapered pants pattern Vogue 9906 (1998) Image: eBay.
Vogue Elements coat or jacket pattern Vogue 9910 (1998) Image: Etsy.

Without being a direct copy, this white formal dress from Begotten by Dilek Atasu — also sized for petites — evokes Buffy’s Spring Fling dress in the season 1 finale (seen under a pleather jacket at the top of this post). Buffy’s prom dress was custom-made for the production: as Puisto recalls, “It was a four-way stretch silk from ISW [LA’s International Silks and Woolens]” with a silk satin bodice and silk chiffon overlay. (Source: Re-Vamped with Juliet Landau)

Simplicity 8985 by Begotten (1999) Image: Donna’s General Store.
Buffy (Sarah Michelle Gellar) with Xander and Angel (Nicholas Brendon and David Boreanaz) in "Prophecy Girl" (Buffy season 1 finale (e12), 1997)
Buffy (Sarah Michelle Gellar) in “Prophecy Girl” (Buffy the Vampire Slayer season 1 finale, 1997) Costume design: Susanna Puisto. Image: 20th Century Fox / Screen Rant.

Sew your own Slayer coat

For Buffy’s heroic look in the first part of the season 2 finale, “Becoming,” Bergstrom paired lilac, stretch trousers from LA’s Mark Wong Nark with a turquoise blue, knee-length jacket by Cynthia Rowley — known to fans as her “slow-mo” coat from the opening credits. The jacket in this early Cynthia Rowley pattern is quite close to Buffy’s “slow-mo” coat, isn’t it? Also sized for petites.

Butterick 6076 by Cynthia Rowley (1999) Strapless dress, jacket, and stole. Image: Etsy.
Buffy running in a Cynthia Rowley coat in "Becoming Part 1" (s2 e21)
Buffy running in a Cynthia Rowley jacket in “Becoming Part 1” (Buffy season 2 finale, 1998) Costume design: Cynthia Bergstrom. Image: 20th Century Fox / EW.com.

Happy Halloween!

2 responses to “Prophecy Girl”

  1. Liz Haywood Avatar

    Thank you for the nostalgia! I had the Vogue 9910 coat pattern and made the longer length in silver vinyl. Wore it with blue eye shadow and thought I was pretty hot stuff 🙂

    1. Sarah Sheehan Avatar

      Thanks, Liz! Your version sounds fabulous. I can picture the blue.

Leave a reply to Liz Haywood Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.